Lemon Poke Pudding Cake: Soft, Creamy & Bakery-Worthy Treat

Question 1

Why does my Jello poke cake get soggy?

Accepted Answer

The number one reason poke cakes turn soggy is too much filling, too soon. If you pour warm pudding or gelatin onto a hot cake, it sinks and over-saturates the bottom. To fix this, allow your cake to cool at least 20 minutes and your pudding to chill and thicken slightly before combining them.
Also, don’t poke giant holes — thin ones spaced evenly across the surface allow the pudding to absorb without pooling. After pouring, let the cake set uncovered for 30 minutes in the fridge. That initial exposure helps moisture evaporate gently and preserves that perfect fluffy texture.

Question 2

What happens when you add a box of pudding to a cake mix?

Accepted Answer

Magic. That’s what happens. When you add a dry pudding mix directly into a cake batter, it makes the cake more moist, dense, and flavorful. It adds structure without dryness — perfect for poke cakes.
But remember, this is different from adding prepared pudding after baking, like we do here. The dry mix goes into batter before baking. For poke cakes, you prep the pudding and pour it over afterward to fill those lovely pockets. If you're curious about both methods, several cake recipes explore the difference with delicious results.

Question 3

How do you put pudding in the middle of a cake?

Accepted Answer

You have two options: you can poke holes in a baked cake (like we do here), or you can slice a layer cake and spread pudding between layers like a filling.
For poke cakes, use a chopstick or fork to make clean holes in the top, and pour the pudding gently over the surface. Spread with a spatula for even coverage, and refrigerate for at least 4 hours. The pudding sinks into the holes and firms up as it chills.
To layer it traditionally, let the cake cool fully before slicing and spreading pudding in between — but you’ll need a thicker consistency to prevent it from sliding out.

Question 4

How to make a box cake taste like a bakery cake?

Accepted Answer

Easy upgrades make all the difference. Use milk instead of water, melted butter instead of oil, and add one extra egg than the box calls for. That combination gives you richer flavor, tighter crumb, and moist texture — exactly what bakery cakes have.
Want to add a zesty punch? Mix in lemon zest or a teaspoon of lemon extract to bring out natural citrus notes. Then pair it with a silky pudding layer, and you’ve got bakery flavor with weeknight ease.
For even more ways to take boxed mixes to the next level, check out our quick & easy and holiday recipe ideas.

Ingredients

Instructions

Notes

Nutrition